Tried & True Favorites of Follow Your Heart Café

We hear it all the time - “Your menu is so big, I don’t know what to order!”

We get it, our menu is 4 pages long (5, if you include weekend brunch!) and we have a large range of options from healthy salads and fresh pressed organic juices to classic diner items like burgers and sandwiches, tacos and lasagna, even a Indian Tofu Curry!

So, to help you decide, we put together the ultimate list of the Tried and True Favorites of FYHMC! We certainly couldn’t fit it all, but we think it’s a good introduction to our 56 year old restaurant.

Pot Pie

Our bestselling item on the menu. The pastry and filling are all handmade from scratch in our kitchen. Served with our Marinated Beet Salad and Sauteed Kale.

Sauteed Kale

This one deserves its own place on the list because…if you try it, you’ll know. So simple but so addictively delicious.

Fried Chicken Sandwich

This, or any of our burgers! On our fluffy, housemade buns.

Chili Cheese Fries

Our beloved House Chili on top of our Fries with dairy-free cheese. Our Chef wanted to mention that it is all about the base: our house-cut, twice-fried organic potato fries. The simple things done right!

Fettuccine Alfredo with Daring Foods "Chicken"

The best kind of comfort food.

Reuben Sandwich

A customer favorite in both the cafe and our grab n’ go deli. Made with housemade deli slices and rye!

Mac n’ Cheese.jpg

SONY DSC

Taco Salad

If you are craving something fresh but filling, this is the one!

Avocado Tomato & Sprouts Sandwich

A special mention, because its been a staple on our menu since 1971. And it’s SO good.

Triple Chocolate Cake

Look at that silky smooth ganache on top! The perfect way to end your meal (or take one home from the market.)

Vanilla Raspberry Cake

One of the most recent additions to our line of cakes, but an instant classic.

Send this blog post to someone who HASN’T been to our cafe yet, then make a plan to come together!